A review by acourtoffairytale
House of Flame and Shadow by Sarah J. Maas

3.0

Okay so, 3.5 ✨

I think it's clear that SJM knows how to intertwine stories, and she knows how to write a start, and a middle, but she DOES NOT know how to write endings.
It was clearly a second draft, everything felt rushed, like telling a story you have already told before, sparing a lot of details.

Now: ⚠️spoilers⚠️:

The crossover was disappointing, I wasn't waiting for acotar5, but we didn't even see Feyre talk, not even Rhys was the main character of the crossover, just
SpoilerNesta and Azriel
. And even then, the only thing they did was
Spoilerwalk on a cave looking at walls
. 200 pages for that!!! And then some at the end, like if you're going to do a crossover, do it properly.

And don't get me started on the subtle mention of ToG with the
SpoilerWyrm and Brann...


I didn't understand at all the Lidia storyline, I didn't care about
SpoilerLidia's Sons
, the same way I didn't care about Emile and Sofie in CC2, it was useless to the storyline, put there only to tell us
SpoilerLidia's background story.


The same with Hunt's storyline. Why tell us he's
SpoilerHel's son
if that didn't make him any special? Not even more powerful, just that he could have
Spoilertake out the halo himself all this time
, we already knew he could power Bryce up. Also, he was all angry and that about finding out, just to forget 1 chapter later, and suddenly he wasn't angry anymore.

Overall, i think the start was slow, but with
SpoilerLidia's rescue
it picked up the story and flowed somewhat nicely until 300/350 pages at the end.

The ending felt anticlimactic, like it was too easy to
Spoilerkill the Asteri
, we didn't even see anything about the battle, and as always SJM main characters are always
Spoilerout of power
when you need it the most... If you've read ToG or Acotar, the battle felt repetitive, it's always the same, except this time we had
Spoilerblack holes