4.5 because there were some questionable inconsistencies; otherwise WOW!

I cried actual tears. The sexual tension was UNBELIEVABLE and I loved every hot second of it. The characters were real. I can forgive that Callypso is such a pretentious name because I love the girl that she was and the woman that she is. Desmond is a dream. Temper is the kind of friend I want in my life. And shit, I'm not even mad at Eli.

The Otherworldly mystery could've been hashed out more, instead the book focuses on Callie and Des' relationship. We have two more books to look forward to, and I wait with bated breath.