Five perfectly obliterating stars. I loved every second of this. Sherry Thomas is at the absolute top of her game. I finished this and set my head in my hands and took deep breaths for about five minutes. I screamed a lot. All my favorite characters and plot threads came back. I should write something coherent but the way I feel about this book isn't coherent. Holy character development. Kate Reading doing The Most and giving me bi panic every time she narrates Charlotte. Treadles sweating through every interrogation of his GD life. Ash. (Ash!).